This is one of the follow up posts to yesterday's post Key factors of "strength" in "post Doha" (and post WTO?) world systemics and on the occasion of the G8 meeting in Deauville (France), today and tomorrow.
The G8 started as G6 in the 1970s with France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the UK and the United States ie 4 large and "rich" (GDPwise) European countries members of the then EEC plus USA and Japan (also large and rich, see yesterday's post). Canada was invited later, and later Russia.
The EU is an extra, "associate" type of, participant.
My observations and points:
1) With G20 now in existence, what is G8 for?
2) Since the EEC is EU (since the 1990s) what is the point/sense of having France, Germany, Italy and the UK?
3) Considering Canada's population size compared to the other 7, why is it there (plus China and Brazil are in 2010 GDP terms richer than Canada)
4) Why is China (No. 1 in population and No. 2 in GDP) not there?
5) India is marginally less rich than Canada and Russia (1.4 vs 1.6 and 1.6 trillion USD 2010 see yesterday's article).
Hence, and depending of the weigt attached to GDP and population, the G8 should be:
A) G4: EU, USA, China and Japan
B) G7: EU, USA, China, Japan, India, Russia; plus Brazil (or the UNASUR).
The current G8 seems so 20th century and so globally irrelevant to 2011!
And in any case, EU members states have no place there, the EU does.
See also: Key factors of "strength" in "post Doha" (and post WTO?) world systemics
- December (16)
- November (24)
- October (24)
- September (21)
- August (33)
- July (10)
- June (12)
- May (19)
- April (33)
- March (39)
- February (23)
- January (12)
- December (8)
- November (5)
- October (14)
- September (19)
- August (40)
- July (35)
- June (43)
- If Germany is (really) tired of being the largest ...
- EU Dynamics: 19.5 years after (the mistake in) Maa...
- Re a UN seat for the EU
- "Did you hear the News? Another Day, Another Night...
- The EEC was never (mainly) about economics
- What are France, the UK, Germany and Italy doing i...
- Key factors of "strength" in "post Doha" (and post...
- Walls (bis)
- Eurozone & global systemics: Lessons from Greece's...
- The cheap, hard or smart way to EUrope?
- That anti-inflation obsession: from Bundesbank to ...
- Eurozone: The elephant in the room
- Democracy vs Financial Agorocracy and the value of...
- Systemics: If finance is to remain global then pol...
- Time of EUropean political and opinion leaders to ...
- Eurozone systemics: At the core of the problem
- The times call for public policies, but what kind ...
- EU Systemics: A political union of the Scandic+Bal...
- Systemics: If Greece, Portugal and Ireland formed ...
- Systemics: If the PIIGS formed a political union i...
- The pop culture that unites Europe!
- German exports record high in March vs Euro/USD ra...
- The EU's No. 1 problem is .....
- US - China talks: Who holds the chips?
- Europe or EU Day?
- Why have the dotcom & then subprime bubbles occurr...
- Bank of England keeps its rate at 0.5%. Lessons fo...
- EU vs Eurozone vs Europlus population systemics
- To paraphrase Bill Clinton, "The (Eurozone) periph...
- March 2011 annual retail volume decline larger in ...
- Updated! Industrial Producer prices hikes among Eu...
- March 2011 UK Industrial Producer Prices up 10.8% ...
- EU & Eurozone "naked" against global winds (or whi...
- Beyond greedy Finance and dogmatic Economics
- Capital vs Humans, the EPP, PES, ELDR way?
- Capital vs Humans, the EU way?
- Une fois, une seule fois (poem)
- April (20)
- March (19)
- February (7)
- January (13)
- December (1)
- November (12)
- October (2)
- September (8)
- August (4)
- July (19)
- June (14)
- May (14)
- April (33)
- March (37)
- February (16)
- January (87)
- December (81)
- November (38)
- October (103)
- September (167)
- August (135)
- July (54)
- June (62)
- May (36)
- April (3)
- March (1)
- February (2)
- January (4)